| The Minder Brain | Joe Herbert |

| Introduction Chapter 1 Chapter 2 Chapter 3 Chapter 4 Chapter 5 Chapter 6 Chapter 7 Chapter 8 Chapter 9 Chapter 10 Chapter 11 Chapter 12 Chapter 13 Buy the book |
Excerpts: The
helicopter takes us to this uninhabited valley, lush and distant. We
land in a clearing, and our pilot helps us unload several
packages for our 4 day stay. It only takes a few minutes, and
with a cheerful wave he takes off, leaving us with the intense silence
you only get in utterly remote parts of the world. We unpack, checking
that we have no phone or any other sort of communication: after all, we
want to be alone for the next few days. Then we notice that there
doesn’t appear to be any food. Surely this wasn’t
planned? No matter, we say to each other in the euphoria of
a new exp
erience: we’ll live off the land. After all, our
forebears did just this. The valley looks verdant and fertile,
and we can hear the noise of running water nearby.It’s only after we have put up our little tent, and arranged our deliberately meagre belongings, that we begin to feel hungry. We look around for something to eat. There isn’t anything remotely edible. Plenty of trees, but we can’t really eat leaves. Fruit or berries? There isn’t any obvious fruit around, and the few red berries give a warning rather than an appetising signal. We realise that in the primeval world food doesn’t lie around. You have to go and get it. Know where to look. Find it. Catch it. Even compete for it……… The body doesn’t ‘know’ anything about your energy supply, or whether you need food, or whether you have enough stored energy; but the brain does. And it does a very good job. As we sit on a grassy hillock in our picturesque but apparently food-free valley, dreamily thinking about hamburgers, we recall that our body weight has, for the most part, remained quite steady for the last ten years or so, as is the case for most (but not all) people…….. There’s good evidence that your brain senses changes in blood glucose, and also in insulin, and that this may play a part in satiety. As you break down the protein in your food, levels of amino-acids, which are the building blocks of proteins, increase in the blood. These, too, may signal to the brain that you have eaten. And your liver, which is busily converting your food to useful compounds, also sends its own signals to the brain. Regulating food intake is so important that the brain gets multiple chemical messages about the food you eat. In general, the more information the brain has, the more accurate its control. The body makes sure that the brain has lots of information about food intake……… Obesity is the last thing on our minds as we contemplate a hungry day or so, and try to think of ways of getting something to eat in our picturesque valley, but it’s very much on the minds of health care professionals in the US and Europe. Obesity is officially defined as having a body mass index (BMI) of 30 or over. The
proportion of people with a BMI of 30 or more has increased
dramatically in the US over the past 20 years or so: about 25-30% of
all adults are currently classified as obese, and the EU countries are
fast catching up. It’s an obesity epidemic ........Scientists struggle to explain this epidemic of obesity, let alone do anything about it. Animals eat when they can, and as much as they can: the next meal may be a long way away. So, we presume, did primeval man. If there are enforced periods of starvation, a common event in the natural world, then an array of physiological adaptations exist to defend the body against reduced energy supplies; but there was no need to take account of excess energy stores – they rarely if ever happened. There may be other factors. Palatability is one. Modern techniques in food manufacture are designed to make food more appetising. How often have you, at the end of a large meal, incapable of another mouthful, accepted that Belgian chocolate?....... There was the persistent notion that the brain might have a more dedicated chemical code for eating. This idea had to wait for the surge of work on peptides in the 1970s and onwards. In particular, until a peptide called neuropeptide Y was infused into the brain……. Infuse a tiny amount of neuropeptide Y (called NPY for short) into the brain, and the animal eats and eats. If you infuse NPY every day it puts on lots of weight. NPY is the most powerful appetite stimulant known……. Eating is such an important activity that it would be odd if it were controlled by only one peptide. You eat for many reasons. And you eat different things: sometimes preferring carbohydrate, at another time fat; your body has the ability to signal its needs to the brain. You will know that people from different cultures have different tastes in food. You acquire your taste in food as you grow up. One of the recent social changes in the UK has been the ease with which people adopt new foods. It wasn’t always like this. A previous generation regarded foreign food with suspicion and dislike. There are heart-rending accounts of people starving to death in a famine rather than eat the strange foods provided by an earlier generation of foreign aid agencies. Rats are the same. They are very wary of new food. They need to be: eating something they haven’t tried before can be a fatal business. But damage their amygdala [part of the limbic system] , and they eat it with gusto. A warning system has been disabled….. Anorexia nervosa was only recognised as a discrete condition in the late 19th century, though it took longer for it to be accepted as a disorder. Voluntary food restriction (fasting) has been known since the dawn of recorded history, particularly as part of religious observance. There has been a very marked increase in anorexia during the last twenty or thirty years, overwhelmingly in young women, a fact that has attracted a variety of explanations. It’s a disorder of puberty (though it can occur during the prepubertal or the post-pubertal years), which immediately suggests a hormonal explanation. And it’s particularly prevalent in those in whom minimal body weight is an advantage - models, ballet dancers, athletes – which suggests a social factor – though do anorexics become ballet dancers or vice-versa?... But we also use food as a social instrument…..Thus the tribute to kings and chieftains was often based on gifts of food, and even today we continue the practice, taking bottles of wine to parties, sending chocolates to those we love or presents of food to those we want to influence, doing business over lunch and courting those we fancy over candle-lit suppers… Scientific and literary quotes. |