The Minder Brain            Joe Herbert
coverstrip

Chapter 13. Individuality
This chapter considers the role of genetic variation in the ability of individuals to adapt to unusual demands, and how genes interact with a person’s environment to influence survival and success


  Introduction       
Chapter 1

Chapter 2

Chapter 3

Chapter 4

Chapter 5

Chapter 6

Chapter 7

Chapter 8

Chapter 9

Chapter 10

Chapter 11

Chapter 12

Chapter 13

Subject index



Buy the book


Your comments
Excerpts

Individuality means different things.  You think of yourself as an individual – you are different from anybody else in the world.  Your biological make-up is different  -  there is unlikely to be anyone identical to you anywhere, unless you happen to have an identical twin, and even he/she will have differences. You look out into the world from the ‘person’ lying somewhere just behind your eyes: everyone else looks at you.  Your experience is different from anybody else’s;  even though the fabric of your life may be made up of familiar threads, the exact way they are woven makes a  pattern dic13p2fferent from everybody else’s. Even if someone else had, extraordinarily, experienced everything you have experienced, the results  would still be different, since the ‘you’  to which all this has happened is different from anybody else.  Whether you are a socialite or a recluse, shy or outgoing, other people make up a large part of your pattern of life.  Whilst we all  think of ourselves as individuals, taking our own decisions, in fact much of what we all do is influenced,  determined or directed by the other people, their needs, their priorities as well as our own necessities…….. 

The brain’s serotonin system is activated by stress.  This may help the brain resist the stress or adapt to it.  Released serotonin is sucked back into the nerves that contain it by a special  protein (an uptake protein) which limits its action. The gene that makes this protein has a polymorphism (in this case one that involves a ‘repeated’ sequence).  So a person can have either two ‘short’ forms (no repeat), two ‘long’ ones, or one of each.  You can’t tell by looking at  them.  But should such a person be exposed to a ‘life event’  ( a bad stress) then something extraordinary emerges.  Those with two ‘short’ genes (and hence a slightly altered duration of action of serotonin) are more likely to become depressed…….

The influence the genetic mix has in an individual may, in turn, depend on the nature of the challenge: resisting a period of starvation may be influenced by very different genetic patterns than, say, coping with sustained stress at work.  But we can see the way forward, if dimly, into this immense jungle of  genetic complexity.  Over the next decade or so, this science will move progressively from statements about groups (‘middle management is more stressed and liable to heart attacks than the top brass’) to those about individuals (‘John Roe is middle manager with this genetic make-up, this early set of experiences, this current social environment, this set hormonal and other measures and his chance of a stress-related heart-attack is..…’ ). This will lead to an equally precise and individually-tailored ability to intervene before John gets his heart attack (‘if we lower/ increase John’s ….. by …… amount, then we will reduce his chances of an attack by ….; whereas in Jim it wouldn’t be worth it etc ’)….

Don’t let all this, fascinating as it may be, lull you into thinking that genes are the only formative influence on the brain  we bring to the survival battle.  The brain passes through a period during which it is particularly sensitive to either environmental or biochemical events.  Individual differences in the way these occur  can have long-lasting – some would say permanent – effects.  This ‘critical’ period occurs during early life.  For example, separate a baby rat from its mother for an hour or so for a few days; when it becomes adult it will show exaggerated stress responses compared to its sibling that has experienced a more tranquil maternal environment.  Prenatal ‘stress’ may also have long-term effects: treat rat embryos with a hormone similar to cortisol (the stress hormone) and they show reduced growth, but also insulin resistance and abnormal levels of stress hormones as adults…………..

There’s a rather stri
c13p1king example of the importance of individual differences in the limbic brain and the cortex.  Show twenty people a ham sandwich and a typewriter (to use a famous example) and all will agree on which is which, and what is what.   That’s the cortex: it needs to be accurate about analysing the environment or you won’t survive for long.  Do it ten times and you’ll get the same answer.   But then ask the twenty about how they feel about the ham sandwich.  Those that have just eaten find it rather unappealing, whereas those that missed lunch might find it very attractive.  A few hours later, these responses might be reversed.  A vegetarian, or an orthodox Jew, or someone with a food allergy to ham, might never want the ham sandwich. Nobody, of course, tries to eat the typewriter.  In contrast the analytical cortex, the functional activity of the limbic system is highly variable, either in the long or shorter term, depending on wants, preferences and social customs……..


Scientific and literary quotes.